Litinfinite Journal | ISSN: 2582-0400 [Online]

LITINFINITE JOURNAL
ISSN: 2582-0400 [Online]
CODEN: LITIBR

Peer-reviewed Journal of Literature and Social Sciences  

Open Access Journal

Litinfinite Journal is indexed by MLA Directory Of Periodicals & MLA International Bibliography, DOAJ, EBSCO, ProQuest, SCILIT, Ulrichsweb & Ulrich’s Periodicals Directory, ICI World Of Journals, J-Gate, JISC, ERIH PLUS & other major indexing services 

HSP's Rack Picture 1900 by John Frederick Peto | Courtesy of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art

Litinfinite Journal 

Vol-6, Issue-1 | July, 2024

Literature, Media, Culture and Censorship

Content

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-1 | 2nd July, 2024

Litinfinite Journal

Vol-6, Issue-1 | 2nd July, 2024

Content

 

Article Title

Authors

Pagination

 

Content

 

 

 

Editorial

Sreetanwi Chakraborty

i-ii

1

How to Avoid the Paradigm of Censorship: Self-Consciousness, Mimetic Desire and the Empathic Style of Anita Desai

Manodip Chakraborty

1-9

2

Michael Madhusudan Dutt’s The Captive Ladie: Text Context and Perspectives.

Dr. Sutanuka Ghosh Roy

10-20

3

Obscene and Perverse Fictions: Saadat Hasan Manto and Censorship

Monalisa Jha

21-27

4

Woman-Nature Interface: An Ecofeminist Study by Dipak Giri

Dr. Monika Malhotra

28-30

5

A review of Christian Education and Democracy in India edited by George Thadathil

Shiba Khatoon

31-33

 

Editorial
Sreetanwi Chakraborty
Chief-Editor- Litinfinite Journal
Assistant Professor
Amity Institute of English Studies and Research
Amity University Kolkata

The history of literature is replete with multiple instances of protest and censorship. Words, phrases, sentences, sentiments and emotions have constantly been thwarted on various pretexts. Suppression of voice and individual spaces have always been there as a part of any dominant culture. Media too, has a significant role to play in the culmination, dissemination and even in the repression of protest through atrocities. There has been the best of times now, and the worst of times as the opposite. With gender-based, caste-based, creed-based and community-based violence and oppression on the rise, literature becomes a powerful tool to highlight the voice of the marginalized. National and international contexts in which protest, censorship and the criticism occupy a centrestage have been negated very often by powerful media houses, and on the other hand, literature in that direction has played a significant role in creating an all-encompassing region of going beyond the brutalities of censorship. There can be prevention, encryption, destruction and omission of sensitive literature or cultural information. Numerous ways in which the acts of writing can be suppressed can also fall under the category of creative censorship.

The current issue of Litinfinite Journal (Volume 6, Issue 1) is on ‘Literature, Media, Culture and Censorship.’ The aim of this issue is to look at the multifaced and interwoven characteristics of literature, culture, and media in terms of the applicability and the unforeseen consequences of censorship. The first paper titled How to avoid the paradigm of censorship: Self-consciousness, mimetic desire and the empathic style of Anita Desai by Manodip Chakraborty investigates the major social forces in the writing of Anita Desai and how the knowledge and boundaries of desire and self-absorption are often seen as the paradigmatic opposite to censorship. Manodip writes how ‘The censoring paradigmatic conception of ‘permitted’, ‘allowed’, or ‘functional’ interest in defining a human factor proved confusing to literary writers, when they have compared the ‘ideal’ as proposed by the censorship and the ‘real’ that these censorships are trying to prevent.’ (Chakraborty 2) The next paper by Dr. Sutanuka Ghosh Roy explores and reinstates the intricate layers of censorship in Michael Madhusudan Dutt’s ‘The Captive Ladie’: Text Context and Perspectives. Her paper questions that very fabric of identity politics and its diversification. Moreover, there is a subtle hinting of what the essence of nationalism entails. She interprets The Captive Ladie from social, cultural and political contexts and writes: ‘A probe into the poem reveals that the first and last paragraphs of the poem are arranged in a similar vein and the four paragraphs in the middle are of different types. The most striking feature of the poem is Dutt’s patriotism. He was a follower of the West in 1841 and considered Albion as his native land.’

We also have one more research paper in this volume. It is titled, Obscene and Perverse Fictions: Saadat Hasan Manto and Censorship written by Monalisa Jha. She examines the nature of obscene and perverse in terms of cultural normativity and the proclivity of Manto in renegotiating the boundaries of culture, censorship, media and obscenity in general. She refers to Foucault’s ideas about government, political system, learning and unlearning the concepts of a nation state. Monalisa observes, ‘In a society which at best ignored and at worst actively suppressed the idea of adolescent sexuality, where discussion of sexuality was regarded as unclean and outside the realm of the polite public sphere, Manto boldly traces the sexual awakening of twelve-year-old Masud, as he sees smoke rising from the freshly cut goat meat in the bazaar, and then thinks of his sister’s limbs as akin to the meat as he massages her legs.’ (Jha 22)

We also have two book reviews in this issue. Dr. Monika Malhotra reviews the book Woman-Nature Interface: An Ecofeminist Study by Dipak Giri and Shiba Khatoon reviews the book A review of Christian Education and Democracy in India edited by George Thadathil. Woman-Nature Interface, as self-explanatory, with ideas of patriarchal domination and ecofeminism taking centrestage. The book is an edited volume consisting of chapters that are introspective in nature, on the role and status of women vis-à-vis the active environment. As Dr. Malhotra opines through her critical lens: ‘how religious and cultural narratives perpetuate these constraints, and how ecofeminists strive to overcome them. The book also talks about third world countries where Earth is represented as a female Mother earth and Virgin land. Both suffer exploitation and violence at the hands of patriarchal capitalist society. Apart from this, the book also depicts that the nexus between nature and woman has been the focus of ancient Indian literature.’ (Malhotra 29). The next book, A review of Christian Education and Democracy in India edited by George Thadathil is critically read by Shiba Khatoon who takes into consideration the huge literary, cultural, social, political and religious impact that this book can have. The history of Christian education intertwined with layers of democracy are susceptible to multiple interpretations. As the researcher Khatoon observes: ‘The book helps in understanding the context (vision) which led to the development of the Indian Constitution while appreciating diverse perspectives with a single motive of the development of the people into a true democratic country. The Editor, upholding a similar spirit and vision, welcomed diverse perspectives from a cross section of people in bringing this book to its fruition with the unwavering motive of highlighting the relentless contribution of Christian Education towards the making of Indian Democracy’. (Khatoon 32)

I hope our readers, scholars, researchers and faculty will derive the necessary academic nourishment from Litinfinite Vol. 6, Issue 1.

I express my heartfelt thanks to all our esteemed editors, reviewers, and contributors.

I offer my sincerest thanks to Penprints Publication, for their constant technical support.

Thanking You,

Sreetanwi Chakraborty
Chief-Editor- Litinfinite Journal
Assistant Professor, Amity Institute of English Studies and Research
Amity University Kolkata. West Bengal, India.
Mail ID: [email protected] | ORCID ID: 0000-0002-2936-222X

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.1-9

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-1 | July, 2024 | Page: 1-9

How to Avoid the Paradigm of Censorship: Self-Consciousness, Mimetic Desire and the Empathic Style of Anita Desai

Manodip Chakraborty
Research Scholar
IIT Guwahati, Assam
Mail id: [email protected] | Orcid – 0000-0001-9366-679X

Abstract

Anita Desai and her writings have surfaced undoubtedly as a significant expression of contemporary domestic atmosphere – voicing suppressions, subjugations, embedded violence, and/ or culturally dominant structural family patterns. It is without a doubt then, her writings too have been subjected to censorship binaries, but somehow passing through them is voicing the emanant. What then she embedded in her writings, how she had codified the narratives, which even though stands in antagonism to the prevalent cultural patterns – still is finding an outlet without obscurity? The answer lies in the narrative choice of her stories. The plots, instead of featuring an alien story features a familiar story (a characteristic feature of mimetic desire). Amalgamated with this is her unique capability of using semiotics of self-consciousness. Combined, both these devices make her readings a direct apprehension of a phenomenon in a not-so-direct manner. This paper thus proposes to analyze selected works of Anita Desai’s to understand her use of self-consciousness and mimetic desires of her characters as a potential device to penetrate the censorship stigmata.

Keywords: Apprehension, Diachronic Temporality, Embeddedness, Anti-Expression, Enumeration

Chakraborty, Manodip. “How to Avoid the Paradigm of Censorship: Self-Consciousness, Mimetic Desire and the Empathic Style of Anita Desai” Litinfinite Journal, vol. 6, no. 1, July. 2024, pp. 1–9. https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.1-9.

Michael Madhusudan Dutt’s The Captive Ladie: Text Context and Perspectives.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.10-20

Dr. Sutanuka Ghosh Roy

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-2 | July, 2024| Page: 10-20

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.10-20

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-1 | July, 2024 | Page: 10-20

Michael Madhusudan Dutt’s The Captive Ladie: Text Context and Perspectives.

Dr. Sutanuka Ghosh Roy
Associate Professor in English, Tarakeswar Degree College, The University of Burdwan, West Bengal. India.
Mail Id: [email protected] | Orcid – 0000-0001-8321-3607

Abstract

     Michael Madhusudan Dutta (1824-1873) is a revered name in Bengali Literature. To gauge his merit is an arduous task. It is he who changed the literary sky of Bengali literature with grace and elan. He began writing English poetry at the age of seventeen and started sending his works to publications in England, including Blackwood’s Magazine and Bentley’s Miscellany. However, his desire to go to England and make a name in English literature became largely unfulfilled. He succumbed to familial pressure and was forced to leave Calcutta for Madras. In 1849 he composed The Captive Ladie a poem of two cantos. This paper is a fresh take on The Captive Ladie beyond the conventional, canonical critical approaches that usually estimate The Captive Ladie from social, and philosophical perspectives, the paper takes recourse to the cultural issues of India as a nation, language ‘differences’, identity politics, personal struggle.

Keywords: English poetry, Bengali Literature, England, Social, identity politics.

Ghosh Roy, Sutanuka. “Michael Madhusudan Dutt’s The Captive Ladie: Text Context and Perspectives.” Litinfinite Journal, vol. 6, no. 1, July. 2024, pp. 10–20. https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.10-20.

Obscene and Perverse Fictions: Saadat Hasan Manto and Censorship

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.21-27

Monalisa Jha

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-2 | July, 2024| Page: 21-27

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.21-27

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-1 | July, 2024 | Page: 21-27

Obscene and Perverse Fictions: Saadat Hasan Manto and Censorship

Monalisa Jha

Assistant Professor, Department of English, Lady Brabourne College, Kolkata, West Bengal, India

Mail id: [email protected] | Orcid – 0009-0001-3703-1471

Abstract

This paper aims to explore how Saadat Hasan Manto, (1912-1955) faced state censorship and social criticism on charges of obscenity and sedition for his stories. The present paper shall seek to trace the charges of obscenity that were laid in colonial India and Pakistan against these stories, in order to trace the national/cultural imaginary through which the nation states of British India and the newly formed state of Pakistan sought to define themselves, to attempt to identify precisely what was found to be threatening in these texts to merit state censorship. The paper asserts that a study of these censorship trials might throw an interesting light on how the South Asian state in its precolonial and then national form imagined itself into being by containing and censoring what was seen as inhospitable to the creation of the governable subject.

Keywords: Censorship, Obscenity, Sedition, Perversity, Subjectivity

Jha, Monalisa. “Obscene and Perverse Fictions: Saadat Hasan Manto and Censorship” Litinfinite Journal, vol. 6, no. 1, July. 2024, pp. 21–27. https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.21-27.

Book Review

Woman-Nature Interface: An Ecofeminist Study by Dipak Giri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.28-30

Dr. Monika Malhotra

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-2 | July, 2024| Page: 28-30

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.28-30

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-1 | July, 2024 | Page: 28-30

Woman-Nature Interface: An Ecofeminist Study by Dipak Giri

Dr. Monika Malhotra

Associate Professor & Head, Department of English, Government Degree College, Akhnoor, Jammu and Kashmir, India.

Mail id: [email protected] | Orcid:  0009-0004-2680-9681

Bibliographic Information:
Name of the Book: Woman-Nature Interface: An Ecofeminist Study
Author: Dipak Giri

Publisher: AABS Publishing House
Language: English
ISBN: 978-93-88963-60-2
Price: INR 899 | $ 20

Malhotra, Monika. “Woman-Nature Interface: An Ecofeminist Study by Dipak Giri” Litinfinite Journal, vol. 6, no. 1, July. 2024, pp. 28–30. https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.28-30.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.31-33

Litinfinite Journal | Vol-6, Issue-1 | July, 2024 | Page: 31-33

A review of Christian Education and Democracy in India edited by George Thadathil

Shiba Khatoon

PhD Scholar, Department of Education, Central University of Kerala, Kasaragod, Kerala, India.

Mail id: [email protected] | Orcid: 0000-0002-4370-6201

Bibliographic Information:

Name of the Book: A review of Christian Education and Democracy in India
Author: George Thadathil (Ed.)

Publisher: Penprints, and Salesian College Publication
Language: English
ISBN: 978-8196657741
Price: INR 900 | $ 20

Khatoon, Shiba. “A review of Christian Education and Democracy in India edited by George Thadathil” Litinfinite Journal, vol. 6, no. 1, July. 2024, pp. 31–33. https://doi.org/10.47365/litinfinite.6.1.2024.31-33.

DOWNLOAD THE COMPLETE ISSUE Litinfinite Journal Volume 6, Issue 1, (July, 2024)

DOWNLOAD THE COVER.